電子署名について

FDAは、1997年8月20日に21 CFR Part 11 “Electronic Records; Electronic Signatures”(以下、Part11)という規則を発行した。
意外と知られていないことであるが、Part11は製薬業界からの要請に従って作成された規則である。
というのも医薬品の製造工程や品質試験が電子化されてきたが、手書きの署名を付すためだけに最終的に紙に印刷を行っていた。
それでは不合理だということになり、業界がFDAに対してペーパーレス化(すなわち電子署名)を認めるための要件を示すように要請したのである。
つまり、Part11は元々は電子署名を中心として検討されてきた経緯がある。
電子署名に求められる要件は、以下の2つである。
1)本人性の確保
2)非改ざん性の確保
いずれも事後否認ができないための措置である。

まず本人性の確保であるが、電子署名を付す場合にはパスワードの入力が必要である。
つまり本人以外は実施できないことが条件なのである。
よくある間違いとして、ログオン時にパスワードを入力しているので、署名時にはパスワードは不要であるといった勘違いである。
ログオンしたまま端末を離れてしまった場合、他人が偽って署名を行うことができてしまうからである。
電子署名を付す際には、必ず1回毎にパスワードの入力が必要である。
ただし、パスワードの管理がずさんであった場合には問題となる。
また他人にパスワードを教えて代理で署名させる行為もできてしまう。
このような行為のことをなりすましと呼ぶ。
なりすましは査察時には絶対に発見することができない。
なぜならば電子署名は手書きの署名とは異なり、筆跡が残らないからである。
そこでFDAは、電子署名を付すことができる者に教育訓練を徹底し、Part11を遵守することの誓約書を書かせるなどの措置を要求している。

次に非改ざん性の証明であるが、電子署名を付した電子記録は変更不可にならなければならない。
万が一、電子記録を変更した場合には、電子署名が無効にならなければならないのである。

手書きの署名の場合には日付をともに記載するが、電子署名の場合は日時分まで要求されている。
これは電子記録と電子署名の前後関係を明らかにし、改ざんを防止する意図がある。

ところで多くの企業が電子署名に関して過剰な対応をしていることがある。
FDAがPart11の厳格な遵守を求めている電子署名は、製品の品質や安全性に関する記録に対する承認行為のみである。
例えば、製造記録、品質試験記録、出荷判定記録などである。
作成者の署名や確認者の署名は、必ずしもPart11規則の遵守が要求されない。
(もちろんPart11を遵守することが望ましいが…)

あまりにもPart11にこだわり、製品の品質や患者の安全性に影響がない記録まで厳格に対応することはいささか過剰品質であると言える。
SOPや教育記録などは必ずしも重要ではないかも知れないとFDAは述べている。
リスクベースドアプローチを採用し、過剰なシステム化投資を避けなければならないと言える。

Related post

Comment

  1. Excellent blog here! Also your sie loads up very fast!
    What webb hosst arre you using? Can I get you affiliate linkk tto youhr host?
    I wish my webb site loaderd upp ass quickly as youjrs lol

  2. behind the counter allergy medicine can flonase make you sleepy allergy pills on sale

  3. can online doctor prescribe ambien order provigil pill

  4. deltasone 10mg without prescription order prednisone 10mg online

  5. best antacid over the counter purchase pepcid pills

  6. dermatologist recommended for acne prednisolone 20mg oral teenage acne treatment for girls

  7. generic allergy medication list albuterol online buy alphabetical list of allergy medications

  8. best over the counter heartburn medicine order allopurinol 100mg online cheap

  9. order accutane 10mg pill isotretinoin 40mg for sale cost isotretinoin

  10. super strong sleeping pills order phenergan sale

  11. amoxil 500mg for sale buy amoxil 250mg sale buy generic amoxicillin

  12. insomnia doctor specialist near me buy modafinil without prescription

  13. purchase zithromax for sale zithromax pills buy zithromax no prescription

  14. oral gabapentin buy generic gabapentin

  15. azipro online buy azipro online order azithromycin 250mg sale

  16. buy generic lasix order furosemide 100mg pills

  17. buy omnacortil 20mg omnacortil tablet order omnacortil 20mg online

  18. La capacidad de tu blog para adaptarse a diversos intereses es algo que aprecio.
    Siempre hay algo para cada tipo de lector. ¡Manteniendo la diversidad
    viva! barras y rieles para cortinas

  19. En tu blog, encuentro respuestas a preguntas que
    ni siquiera sabía que tenía. La forma en que desglosas conceptos complejos facilita el aprendizaje.
    ¡Gracias por hacerlo accesible! ferretería industrial

  20. order amoxil 500mg generic amoxicillin 500mg over the counter purchase amoxil

  21. cheap doxycycline 100mg how to buy doxycycline

  22. generic albuterol buy albuterol pills generic ventolin 4mg

  23. buy augmentin 1000mg order augmentin 375mg pills

  24. levothroid cost synthroid 75mcg us levothroid price

  25. buy vardenafil generic buy levitra 20mg without prescription

  26. La forma en que desmitificas conceptos complicados en tu blog es impresionante.
    Ayudas a que tus lectores se sientan más seguros al abordar
    temas desafiantes. ¡Gracias por simplificar el aprendizaje!

    amoladora ligera – soporte para llaves de tubo

  27. serophene online order serophene order clomid 50mg drug

  28. buy tizanidine paypal zanaflex oral tizanidine medication

  29. buy generic semaglutide for sale semaglutide online semaglutide 14mg ca

  30. buy prednisone 5mg deltasone 10mg uk purchase prednisone

  31. rybelsus 14mg us order rybelsus 14mg sale buy rybelsus 14mg pills

  32. buy accutane paypal order generic accutane 40mg purchase absorica generic

  33. buy albuterol sale ventolin where to buy buy generic albuterol

  34. amoxicillin tablets purchase amoxicillin pill amoxicillin ca

  35. augmentin order online buy amoxiclav pill order generic augmentin

  36. buy azithromycin 250mg generic azithromycin 250mg without prescription oral azithromycin

  37. buy synthroid 75mcg generic order synthroid 75mcg buy generic synthroid 100mcg

  38. Dengan banyak bonus didapatkan dari Galaxy138 sudah pasti benar-benar untungkan kamu dan juga bisa memberikan sensasi lebih di dalam bermain slot gacor belum lagi jackpot besar menanti.

  39. prednisolone 40mg drug cheap prednisolone 20mg purchase prednisolone online cheap

  40. clomiphene ca clomid 50mg pill order clomid sale

  41. gabapentin 100mg over the counter order neurontin 600mg for sale neurontin pills

  42. buy furosemide no prescription buy furosemide 100mg generic order furosemide online

  43. viagra 100mg pills for men purchase sildenafil without prescription purchase viagra pills

  44. purchase monodox pills order doxycycline 100mg generic doxycycline 200mg oral

  45. semaglutide 14mg pills oral semaglutide 14 mg order rybelsus generic

  46. online poker real money blackjack game online gambling money sports gambling

  47. order levitra without prescription buy levitra 20mg without prescription generic vardenafil

  48. pregabalin 150mg over the counter cost lyrica 150mg buy cheap lyrica

  49. buy plaquenil no prescription order hydroxychloroquine 200mg online cheap order hydroxychloroquine 200mg

  50. cost triamcinolone aristocort canada order aristocort sale

  51. order tadalafil 40mg online cheap tadalafil 5 mg tablet tadalafil 5mg usa

  52. order clarinex 5mg for sale order clarinex 5mg generic order clarinex 5mg

  53. order cenforce 100mg pills cheap cenforce buy cenforce 100mg online

  54. buy claritin pill buy claritin medication buy claritin pills for sale

  55. buy aralen 250mg sale chloroquine online order chloroquine pill

  56. buy priligy 30mg sale order dapoxetine 30mg online buy cytotec cheap

  57. purchase glucophage generic order glucophage 1000mg without prescription glucophage pills

  58. xenical 60mg without prescription buy orlistat 120mg generic order diltiazem 180mg online cheap

  59. lipitor 80mg drug order atorvastatin generic atorvastatin 80mg drug

  60. buy zovirax without a prescription cost zyloprim 300mg zyloprim 300mg canada

  61. norvasc pill norvasc 5mg tablet amlodipine 5mg pills

  62. buy lisinopril online cheap prinivil pill zestril usa

  63. purchase rosuvastatin sale cheap rosuvastatin 10mg buy generic zetia online

  64. prilosec 20mg for sale prilosec to treat heartburn prilosec over the counter

  65. domperidone usa order domperidone online cheap buy generic sumycin

  66. metoprolol pills metoprolol without prescription purchase lopressor generic

  67. oral cyclobenzaprine cyclobenzaprine over the counter buy baclofen 10mg online

  68. atenolol online order buy atenolol online tenormin 100mg cost

  69. where to buy toradol without a prescription colcrys online buy colchicine 0.5mg for sale

  70. medrol 4mg tablet methylprednisolone 4 mg over counter methylprednisolone 4mg otc

  71. i need help with my assignment essay helper online essays writing

  72. propranolol drug brand inderal 20mg order clopidogrel 75mg

  73. methotrexate tablet methotrexate 5mg uk oral coumadin 2mg

  74. order meloxicam 7.5mg sale celecoxib uk order celebrex generic

  75. order metoclopramide 20mg generic order reglan for sale cozaar usa

  76. buy flomax online cheap buy celebrex 100mg online cheap celebrex 100mg

  77. order nexium 20mg generic cheap nexium 20mg topamax 200mg oral

  78. order ondansetron 4mg without prescription purchase ondansetron sale spironolactone 100mg generic

  79. order sumatriptan generic buy generic imitrex 50mg how to get levaquin without a prescription

  80. simvastatin 10mg canada order valtrex 1000mg sale buy generic valtrex for sale

  81. avodart 0.5mg oral buy zantac 300mg pills buy zantac online

  82. propecia online buy where to buy finasteride without a prescription purchase diflucan without prescription

  83. ampicillin pills penicillin antibiotic online amoxil buy online

  84. purchase propecia online cheap purchase propecia for sale diflucan drug

  85. buy cipro no prescription – oral cipro purchase amoxiclav for sale

  86. cipro 1000mg oral – purchase baycip online augmentin 625mg brand

  87. purchase ciplox pill – order generic erythromycin 500mg erythromycin 250mg tablet

  88. metronidazole 200mg generic – buy flagyl no prescription brand azithromycin 500mg

  89. ivermectin dosage – sumycin tablet sumycin price

  90. valacyclovir drug – order diltiazem 180mg pill zovirax online

  91. Online poker

  92. buy flagyl pills – buy amoxil cheap purchase azithromycin pills

  93. ampicillin online order buy penicillin pills buy amoxicillin for sale

  94. cost furosemide 100mg – buy candesartan 16mg generic order capoten 25 mg online

  95. metformin uk – bactrim 960mg pills lincomycin 500mg brand

  96. buy pill generic retrovir – irbesartan online order brand zyloprim 300mg

  97. oral clozaril 50mg – glimepiride order online purchase famotidine

  98. buy viagra online

  99. purchase seroquel pills – cheap generic bupropion eskalith price

  100. oral clomipramine 25mg – brand paxil 10mg order sinequan 75mg generic

  101. atarax 10mg cost – hydroxyzine 25mg brand amitriptyline online buy

  102. augmentin 1000mg pill – where to buy bactrim without a prescription baycip for sale

  103. cheap amoxil online – order generic duricef 250mg buy ciprofloxacin pills

  104. azithromycin 250mg pill – buy tetracycline cheap oral ciprofloxacin 500mg

  105. cleocin drug – terramycin 250mg without prescription cheap generic chloramphenicol

  106. ivermectin 3mg pills – buy generic eryc online cefaclor generic

  107. order albuterol online – advair diskus buy online brand theo-24 Cr

  108. depo-medrol tablets – buy methylprednisolone generic cost azelastine

  109. oral clarinex 5mg – purchase desloratadine online cheap order ventolin 2mg pills

  110. order generic micronase 5mg – micronase us purchase dapagliflozin without prescription

  111. glycomet 1000mg cheap – januvia 100 mg for sale order acarbose sale

  112. how to get repaglinide without a prescription – jardiance cheap buy cheap jardiance

  113. buy terbinafine – terbinafine price grifulvin v buy online

  114. rybelsus 14mg price – buy glucovance medication buy desmopressin paypal

  115. order nizoral online – generic itraconazole 100mg purchase sporanox pill

  116. buy generic famciclovir 500mg – buy generic famvir online buy valcivir 1000mg generic

  117. lanoxin 250mg sale – lanoxin 250 mg drug furosemide 40mg us

  118. lopressor 100mg for sale – order micardis online adalat 30mg drug

  119. purchase hydrochlorothiazide – plendil 10mg cost order zebeta 5mg

  120. order nitroglycerin – order combipres online cheap diovan canada

  121. crestor pills wander – pravastatin tell caduet online corp

  122. zocor upstairs – lipitor next lipitor stone

  123. Link exchange is nothing else however it is just placing the other
    person’s webpage link on your page at proper place and other person will also do
    same for you.

  124. viagra professional online pant – levitra oral jelly end levitra oral jelly control

  125. dapoxetine water – suhagra beneath cialis with dapoxetine charge

  126. cenforce online tend – cenforce online roar brand viagra pills evil

  127. brand cialis toy – brand levitra lump penisole seize

  128. cialis soft tabs relax – viagra oral jelly respectable viagra oral jelly habit

  129. brand cialis agree – viagra soft tabs physician penisole ward

  130. excellent submit, very informative. I’m wondering why the other experts of this sector don’t notice this.
    You must continue your writing. I’m sure, you have a huge readers’ base already!

  131. cialis soft tabs online fruit – levitra soft pills intent viagra oral jelly online hate

  132. cenforce online tail – kamagra online stout brand viagra online starve

  133. priligy unusual – viagra plus expensive cialis with dapoxetine scarce

  134. acne medication den – acne treatment alien acne treatment constant

  135. inhalers for asthma battle – asthma medication furniture inhalers for asthma add

  136. treatment for uti face – uti medication other uti treatment churchyard

  137. prostatitis treatment bile – pills for treat prostatitis people prostatitis pills bit

  138. valacyclovir online belt – valacyclovir online reality valacyclovir spark

  139. loratadine medication flow – claritin pills quill claritin rabbit

  140. dapoxetine sherlock – dapoxetine countenance priligy outer

  141. claritin pills sir – loratadine medication defend claritin attend

  142. buy viagra online

  143. ascorbic acid include – ascorbic acid wake ascorbic acid bang

  144. promethazine coat – promethazine route promethazine reserve

  145. biaxin pills sink – cytotec misery cytotec pills shock

  146. fludrocortisone ray – nexium trial prevacid chicken

  147. buy generic rabeprazole for sale – buy rabeprazole 20mg online how to buy motilium

  148. dulcolax for sale – cheap bisacodyl 5 mg cheap liv52 20mg

  149. hydroquinone usa – cerazette 0.075mg tablet buy duphaston 10 mg generic

  150. cotrimoxazole cost – purchase cotrimoxazole pill cost tobrex 5mg

  151. fulvicin 250 mg cheap – order generic griseofulvin lopid price

  152. dapagliflozin 10 mg cheap – dapagliflozin for sale cost acarbose 25mg

  153. dimenhydrinate cost – buy prasugrel 10 mg online order risedronate online

  154. enalapril 5mg without prescription – buy latanoprost online cheap order zovirax generic

  155. order monograph 600 mg generic – etodolac 600 mg price cilostazol 100mg sale

  156. buy piroxicam 20 mg without prescription – feldene online exelon 6mg uk

  157. buy piracetam 800mg generic – buy secnidazole without prescription order sinemet pills

  158. hydrea canada – cost robaxin order methocarbamol online

  159. cost depakote 500mg – diamox 250mg cost topiramate generic

  160. norpace usa – norpace online order buy thorazine generic

  161. buy cytoxan pill – order meclizine 25mg pills order vastarel without prescription

  162. oral spironolactone 25mg – carbamazepine where to buy naltrexone online

  163. order cyclobenzaprine 15mg online cheap – cheap donepezil without prescription vasotec 10mg over the counter

  164. how to get zofran without a prescription – purchase procyclidine sale buy requip medication

  165. ascorbic acid 500 mg oral – kaletra cost prochlorperazine over the counter

  166. durex gel online purchase – purchase durex gel xalatan medication

  167. purchase rogaine online – order propecia 5mg buy propecia 5mg online cheap

  168. order arava 10mg online cheap – how to get alfacalcidol without a prescription cartidin order online

  169. verapamil 240mg for sale – valsartan 80mg us cheap tenoretic for sale

  170. order tenormin 50mg generic – order clopidogrel for sale carvedilol price

  171. purchase atorvastatin sale – cheap lisinopril tablets cheap nebivolol 5mg

  172. purchase gasex for sale – gasex order purchase diabecon generic

  173. buy lasuna paypal – lasuna for sale cheap himcolin pills

  174. cheap noroxin online – confido for sale order confido online

  175. Pretty! This was a really wonderful post. Many thanks for providing this information.

  176. finax where to buy – buy doxazosin for sale uroxatral 10mg ca

  177. speman online – generic finasteride fincar without prescription

  178. order terazosin 5mg pills – dutasteride medication dapoxetine 90mg brand

  179. oxcarbazepine 300mg for sale – oxcarbazepine 600mg oral synthroid 75mcg drug

  180. order imusporin online – order methotrexate colcrys canada

  181. lactulose over the counter – buy duphalac without a prescription order generic betahistine 16mg

  182. how to get deflazacort without a prescription – buy deflazacort generic alphagan online

  183. brand besifloxacin – besivance tubes cheap generic sildamax

  184. buy neurontin online cheap – order gabapentin 100mg pills order azulfidine generic

  185. celecoxib 200mg generic – purchase flavoxate pills cheap indocin

  186. buy colospa 135mg – cilostazol 100 mg drug pletal 100 mg generic

  187. diclofenac 100mg oral – diclofenac generic aspirin 75mg without prescription

  188. buy cheap rumalaya – order shallaki pill endep pills

  189. order mestinon generic – azathioprine order online azathioprine 50mg over the counter

  190. This post really covers the basics well. For those wanting to explore further, I suggest reading this detailed guide on satta king. It’s packed with useful tips.

  191. voveran cost – buy imdur 20mg online cheap buy generic nimotop

  192. baclofen 10mg pill – buy cheap generic piroxicam feldene ca

  193. buy generic periactin for sale – buy tizanidine paypal tizanidine online

  194. mobic 15mg over the counter – cheap meloxicam order toradol 10mg for sale

  195. buy omnicef – clindamycin over the counter cleocin brand

  196. cheap artane sale – trihexyphenidyl pill emulgel buy online

  197. purchase capecitabine online – purchase danazol online cheap buy danocrine no prescription

  198. order prometrium 200mg generic – order progesterone buy fertomid paypal

  199. purchase fosamax without prescription – buy provera 5mg for sale medroxyprogesterone 5mg uk

  200. aygestin 5 mg cost – buy norethindrone 5mg for sale order yasmin

  201. order estrace 2mg pill – purchase estradiol for sale brand arimidex 1mg

  202. dostinex 0.5mg cost – how to get alesse without a prescription alesse usa

TOP